Will EU bring back lamps and luminaires?

DRAFT European regulations seen by Lux have raised the possibility of a return to the days of lighting fixtures with replaceable lamps.

Under the radical proposals, luminaire makers will have make the light source removable and replaceable from the fitting by September 2020.

The draft of the Ecodesign laws states that ‘manufacturers and importers shall ensure that light sources and separate control gears in scope of this Regulation can be readily removed without permanent mechanical damage by the end-user.

Ed Sheeran performing at the Southside Festival 2014 in Neuhausen ob Eck, Germany. Under the EU proposals, most theatrical lighting equipment will become redundant.
Picture copyright 2014 Markus Hillgärtner via WikiMedia Creative Commons

‘Where light sources and separate control gears…cannot be readily removed by the end-user, manufacturers and importers shall ensure that the containing product is designed in such a way that light sources and separate control gears…can be readily removed by qualified professionals’.

The proposals, if adopted, have major implications for how lights are made.

In recent years, as LEDs have come to dominate the market, manufacturers have integrated LEDs and light into one, with the LEDs usually bonded to either a heatsink or the body of the unit. Many fittings, especially those with higher ingress protection ratings, are fully sealed units.

To change to a new method of incorporating the light source would be a major upheaval for those with heavy investments in automation. Additionally, the proposed timescale - of just 28 months – would also be expected to be challenged.

The proposals also see the effective banning of both tungsten halogen and compact fluorescent as light sources in 2020. A minimum efficiency requirement of 85 lumens per watt and a maximum standby power of 0.5W on all light sources will come into force.

This element of the regulations is widely opposed by theatres and live venues, who rely on workhorse light sources such as the HPL single-ended tungsten lamp. This sector of the industry was exempt under previous laws. The Association of Lighting Designers has launched a campaign called Save Stage Lighting to fight the proposals.


  • A detailed presentation on the proposals will be included in the Lighting Fixture Design 2018 conference, which takes place on Wednesday 20 June and Thursday 21 June 2018. Organised by Lux and LEDs Magazine, the event takes place at the Cavendish Conference Centre in London. For more information and to reserve you place, click HERE.

Comments 7

Yes it is good news but there is a big but. There must be a standard set for replacements, we cant be in a position where one manufacturers replacement source for as an example a 600x600 panel is not compatible electrically or mechanically with anothers.

Hooray to the EU. Replaceable LED bulbs means- • More choices when LEDs fail • No need to be a lighting expert to identify failed fittings • No costly electrician call out charge to replace a whole fitting • No waiting in the dark for repairs • No arguing about warranties/guarantees • Less inclination to understand reams of Ts & Cs • No worry that your fittings will become obsolete • Less waste • Simple replacement if you need to change colour beam angle or output. • 100% ability to match replaceable lamps • Better fittings consistency

Well hurrah at last common sense prevails. I've been saying this since day one...... Integrated fixtures maybe efficient but they are certainly not good for the environment. We have many stories where clients have purchased such a thing and 2 years on, 3000 hours use, one fails. Fixture obsolete no perfect matches on the market. What do they do rip our 19 other fixtures and bin them or put up with a mis-match in the ceiling. Well done for all those that banned them. Should never have been allowed in the first place. Will also make it easier to get costs down by offering similar lamps from the Manufacturers...

Please bring back replaceable chips with improved LED LIGHTING output - start with Down lights please. We have such a large waste now and we are adding to landfills.

The problem is on driver,broken driver is easy to replace on most of led lamp.if everyone care about quality replace cost.all will be ok.

You can usually replace the driver without too much trouble. I can imagine it might be a real problem for driverless/direct ac luminaires.

This is what happens when bureaucrats and not engineers make such decisions. Everyone knows the 'weakest horse' is usually the driver. That should be easily swapped out, and not the light source. Backwards thinking.

Leave your comment